A main water shutoff not working during an active leak can leave you unsure whether to keep turning it or call for help.
Salt Lake City homeowners should stop forcing the valve and arrange another safe way to shut off the supply.
Treat continued leaking as an unresolved problem.
Keep people away from the water, stop using affected fixtures, and tell the plumber that the main valve did not shut off the leak.
Contact your water provider for guidance about supply shutoff. Do not operate street equipment or dismantle a valve yourself.

Identify which problem you are seeing
A valve that will not move, a handle that turns without a clear stop, and a closed valve followed by continued water are different patterns.
Tell the responder which one occurred.
Avoid adding a diagnosis such as “the internal seal is broken” unless a professional has confirmed it.
If you are not certain the valve controls the whole house, say that too.
A nearby shutoff may control only a fixture or part of the system.
Do not keep trying other valves to find out during a leak.
Whirlpool's guidance on household water valves warns that excessive force can damage stuck plumbing valves.
Do not add a longer handle, strike the valve, or use a tool to make it turn farther.
If water begins leaking from the valve itself, stop touching it and report the new location.
Keep clear of any nearby equipment or floor area affected by that water.
Do not confuse residual water with safe shutoff
Some water may continue draining after a supply is closed.
Water already in piping or wet building materials does not disappear at the instant a handle moves.
But continued flow can also mean the supply was not fully shut off.
You do not need to settle that distinction by waiting while damage spreads.
Report whether the flow changed, remained steady, or stopped and returned.
Do not choose an arbitrary waiting period as proof that everything is safe.
If another familiar fixture still has normal water flow, include that note if you noticed it during ordinary use.
Do not run multiple fixtures as a prolonged test or leave taps open while waiting for help.
Contact Valley Plumbing's emergency plumbing service and state that the attempted main shutoff did not stop the active leak.
That detail matters more than an unclear valve name.
Ask the correct utility about supply shutoff
Use the water provider named on your account, not simply the closest city office.
Explain that a private leak is active and the household shutoff failed.
Ask what urgent supply-shutoff assistance or directions apply to your address.
For customers served by Salt Lake City Public Utilities, its emergency water page provides the emergency reporting route.
The city describes water interruptions for repairs, but does not promise that every private-valve problem receives the same response or timing.
Leave meter boxes, street valves, and utility equipment to the provider's directions and authorized personnel.
Do not enter a roadway, remove a locked cover, or use a makeshift key because another homeowner's video shows that approach.
In a building with shared plumbing, contact the property manager or building emergency contact as well.
Make clear which unit and rooms are affected so that any wider shutoff can be coordinated appropriately.
Keep access safe while help is arranged
Do not walk through standing water to reach another valve or electrical control.
Keep people away from wet outlets, appliances, and damaged ceilings.
If there is urgent danger to people, leave the area and contact emergency services.
Stop ordinary water use in the affected area, but do not move heavy appliances or open walls to expose a different shutoff.
Safe access can be more important than getting closer to the visible spray.
If the valve is in a dry, safe location, you can describe its location to the arriving professional.
Otherwise, explain why it is inaccessible.
No photograph or label reading is worth entering an unsafe space.
Give the responders the same short account
A useful hypothetical report is: “A pipe is leaking in the basement.
The labeled main valve moved to its usual closed position, but the stream stayed steady.
The basement floor is wet, and we are staying out.”
That description avoids guessing whether the valve, label, or supply arrangement is wrong.
It also tells the next person not to assume the water has already been shut off.
Share the same details with the utility and the plumber.
If one provides new instructions or confirms a shutoff, pass that update to the other.
Leave the supply off. Ask the plumber or utility when it is safe to restore it.
Resolve the valve before normal use starts again
Once the urgent leak is controlled, ask how the household shutoff will be checked and whether its location can be clearly marked.
A valve that failed during an emergency should not be treated as dependable merely because the visible leak has stopped.
If your main water shutoff is not working during a Salt Lake City leak, contact Valley Plumbing for emergency plumbing service.
Report the failed shutoff and coordinate with your actual water provider.
The next step is safe control of the supply and a check of the private plumbing, without further force on the valve.